There has been a great deal of debate during the last 3 years about the amount of government involvement in the health of the nation. Progressive Democrats for instance think that the government should offer Universal health care to all citizens. They are not against a private insurance industry. If private companies wish to offer a higher level of services they have no problems with this. But basic health care should be guaranteed. Conservative Republicans on the other hand promote the idea that government should have no involvement at all in medical care. Not only did they fight like their lives depended on it two years ago to remove any thing like a single payer system, they turned massive attacks on things like Medicare, Planned Parenthood, Social Security and medical/pension benefits for public employees (excluding Congress of course). Progressives complain that health is too important to be left to the vagaries of the market or the potential greed of profit oriented businesses. Conservatives believe that the Government is incapable of running a program this large, that citizens do not have an explicit “Constitutional Right” to health care and that private industry can get the job done more efficiently. Considering the facts we can easily determine which side is correct.
According to CNN Money health care costs will increase more than 5% again this year alone and the past two years have seen nearly 10% increases. Medicare spending on the other hand has increased less than 1% a year. In fact, according to the bi partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the the gap between medicare/medicaid spending, and all other health care in the US, will widen nearly exponentially during the next 50 years under current policies. This essentially means that, dollar for dollar, government financed health care is a great deal more cost efficient than private health care. The CBO projects that medicare/medicaid will grow from 3-4% of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and is expected to grow to 8-10% before 2035. Private health care expenditures on the other hand are expected to grow from 13% of GDP to more than 30% of the GDP. Determining which method is the most cost efficient is simply a matter of looking at the numbers and doing some simple arithmetic.
But not only does our primarily private health care industry incapable of bringing American health care costs down to the level of the rest of the Industrialized world, but they also seem unable to keep up with the production of vital drugs. This is a problem any pharmacy technician in American can tell you about. There have been a large number of reports during the last few years about shortages of life saving drugs in the United States and many stories about people needing to travel to Canada or Mexico, or order online, just to buy the medications they need to stay alive. In 20ll the number of prescription drugs that are in short supplies grew to 267, a number that is 4 times larger than it was in 1995. The reason for this is simple: Under the private system made on an as needed basis. The medical and pharmaceutical industry will not manufacture a single medication that they think that they might not be able to sell, leaving only limited amounts in warehouses. When needs spike however they are caught short. Government control of health care however would require manufacturers to stockpile medications, especially those with life saving implications and most drug shortages would immediately disappearance.
The main argument against Universal Health Care is that would require an increase in taxes. This is a specious argument however. Of course taxes will increase. But if you are already paying the currently huge medical costs now (a healthy family of three will pay several thousand dollars a year on health care alone), and having this system would remove those costs, then paying a few dollars more in taxes seems to make better sense. Especially since all of the numbers actually demonstrate that the government can operate a health care system much more effectively than private industry can hope too.







